I chose St. Andrews Guesthouse because of the quiet, historical architecture, ambiance, location, and safety if offers. I was not disappointed. The room was cozy but had a clean, modern, and spacious bathroom, great water pressure, ecofriendly lighting (turns on when room key is inserted) and remote controlled heating. There are carpets on the tiled floor to help retain heat, comfortable bed and pillows, and exquisite views of the Old City. St. Andrews is around the corner from First Station dining, and right off the trendy Emek Refaim/German Colony neighborhood with several excellent coffee houses in a 10 minute walk. Jaffa Gate is a brisk 20 minute walk (through Mamilla Mall).
I highly recommend for anyone interested in cultural, but modern experience of all Jerusalem offers!